Missing Pound

Keywords: Starter | Arithmetic | Money | Problem Solving | Puzzles

• Chris, Exeter
• Tuesday, June 20, 2006
• "I think they are very good - some of the 'numeracy' starters were a little dry but you seem to have improved them recently. Thanks for taking the time to put these together and making them free. You've earnt your gold star!"
• Anne, Blackburn, Lancashire
• Wednesday, May 23, 2007
• "Good Grief! That had me going (despite being a 30 year old maths graduate!) The waiter's £2 came out of the £27 paid by the three diners. They did pay £27 (3 x £9) and £25 went to the kitchen and £2 to an unscrupulous waiter. Thanks for making me think though!"
• 9yma3, Northcliffe School
• Friday, June 08, 2007
• "The £27 they paid is the £25 for the meal and the £2 the waiter kept."
• *Nikki Jordan, Braunton School, Devon
• Tuesday, June 19, 2007
• "Excellent. Thank you very much for a fabulous set of starters. I use the 'weekenders' if the daily ones are not quite what I want. Brilliant and much appreciated."
• Class 8A (Miss Yuen), St Philomena's School, Carshalton
• Tuesday, June 19, 2007
• "£30 shared equally between three is £10 each.
  
  £25 shared equally between three is £8.33333......(recurring).
  
  (£8.3333...) X 3 + £5 = £10 X 3
  
  So the pound is still there!"
• Stuart Don, Aberdeenshire
• Tuesday, June 19, 2007
• "Right
  
  The £30 is spead out like this
  
  Restaurant:- £25
  
  Waitor:- £2
  
  Customers:- £3
  
  so 25 + 2 + 3 = £30 so the pound is still there
  
  That Waitor is "NAE NICE""
• Joss Dutton, Class 9T3, National Comprehensive School
• Wednesday, October 17, 2007
• "Man thats hard that'll keep me thinking but if they all payed 10 came back with 5, £1 for every one = £23 + £2 = 25 help me!"
• Faizah, Newcastle
• Monday, October 22, 2007
• "The £30 is still there!"
• Katie n Shaz n Cyan n Jess n Jess !, Menzies High School
• Friday, December 14, 2007
• "Here's the real sum;
  
  £25 for Bill !
  £3 for People !
  £2 for Waiter ! SOOOOOOOO......
  
  £25 + £3 + £2 = £30 so the pound hasn't gone anywhere."
• Baran Ulutas, london
• Tuesday, June 03, 2008
• "They have not paid £27 for meal the bill was £25. yes they paid £27 but inculiding £2 which waiter kept for hiself.
  so £25+£2+£3=£30"
• Miss Andrew and Miss Dengure, Nether Hall Learning Campus
• Tuesday, June 10, 2008
• "We found this starter extremly good and the children really enjoyed it and quoted " This was the best starter."
• Elder Class, Petersfield
• Wednesday, June 18, 2008
• "The Pound is still there because:
  £30 - £1x3 = £27.00
  £27.00 - £2.00 = £25.00
  
  So the restaurant gets
  £25 + £2.00 (waiter)
  Guests get £3.00
  Totals £30.00
  
  We thought this was a good starter because it got us thinking!!!"
• Holly Adams, Thistely Hough
• Wednesday, June 18, 2008
• "The pound has not gone any where because if the people paid 10 pounds each,the total was 30 pounds.
  But the waiter came back with 5 pounds meaning they only paid 9 pounds.
  this is the sum.
  Waiter=2 pounds,
  People=3 pounds,
  Bill= 25 pounds.
  25 add 3 add 2 =30 pounds"
• MWS student, Home
• Wednesday, June 18, 2008
• "10x3=30 right and the waiter gives back 1 pound to each person so thats 9x3 which is 27 plus the 2 pounds the waiter took which is £29. but it's really 30-3=27 and 27-2 so the pound hasn't gone anywhere it's to do with the times tables i think."
• Eddy, Huntcliff school
• Thursday, June 19, 2008
• "So what are we looking for? the 30 pounds spent or should we look for the 25 given for the meal:
  each pay £9 (9x3=27) and the waiter keeps £2 so the sum should realy be £27 - £2 = 25 which is what the restaurant got!!!
  real good staters though
  Thanks"
• Farnborough hill Hampshire , year 8 set 1
• Thursday, June 19, 2008
• "they added the 2 twice in both 9x3 and the 27+2. They should have written 27+3 because they paid for the waiters *tip*
  Original cost=£30
  Returned £3
  Waiter kept £2
  therefore they paid £27, instead of £25-the evil waiter stole £2.
  THEIF!!!!!
  woooooooooooooohoooooooooooooo"
• Mrs O'Hagan's 2nd yr class, Holyrood RC Sec , Glasgow
• Thursday, June 19, 2008
• "£25 + £3 + £2 =£30
  
  THE WAITER SHOULD BE FIRED!! "
• year 8 top set, Brockington College
• Thursday, June 19, 2008
• "Charlotte says no it doesn't make sense, but we liked it anyway. More like this please."
• Simran Kaur Kainth, Holyrood RC Secondary School
• Thursday, June 19, 2008
• "The one pound is still there because the waiter =£2
  people =£3
  bill =£25
  
  so they all add up to £30.there we have it there was no one pound missing after all!"
• Ghaya Rashid, Northbury Junior School
• Thursday, June 19, 2008
• "I think he kept the pound for him self!"
• Godwin Amarikwa-Obi, St. Mary's COE School, Hendon, London
• Friday, June 20, 2008
• "I really enjoy using your starter of the day with my students. The missing pound one was a very hard nut to crack."
• Lewis, School
• Thursday, June 11, 2009
• "The money was added up incorrectly. They payed £27. The waiter kept £2 pounds but these 2 pounds are in £27 already we should add the £3 they were given back!"
• Tirzah Cooper,
• Saturday, June 13, 2009
• "£30 - £3=£27 so the waiter kept £2.The 3 people have £1. £27 - the £2 that the waiter has = £25. There is no missing coin. The 3 people have £1 each so £25 + £3 = £28. The waiter has £2 so £28 + £2 = £30."
• ,
• Tuesday, June 16, 2009
• "The waiter kept £2
  27+2 = £29
  Red herring, the waiter did keep £2 while the diners paid £27.
  27-2 = 25
  money taken - waiters take = bill at the restaurant.
  compare the meerkat dot com ... simples
  Mr Leigh."
• Cassie Heart Of The National Forest &+ Jack, Castlerock High School!
• Wednesday, June 17, 2009
• "Right
  whilst one was calculating the sum, one come across a discovery that there was no missing pound.
  2+3=5
  £25 SPENT
  25+5=30.
  So therefore there was no missing pound sterling."
• Mr P, Dorset
• Thursday, June 18, 2009
• "The bill totalled £25 so the customers would each have paid £8.33r NOT £9. So each would get £1.67 change
  It is not the waiter's right to keep any money left over but the customers really should have given a tip. However, if the waiter was that dishonest I wouldn't tip him at all!
  No missing pound, just customers out of pocket and a cheeky waiter not declaring his tips."
• Yr 6/7 Class, Stirling East PS
• Friday, June 19, 2009
• "We really enjoyed the question. It provoked a lot of discussion.The waiter's 2 pounds should be taken not added and 27 pounds subtract 2 pounds is 25 pounds which was the original bill."
• Farhana Khatun, Azhar Academy 9B
• Friday, June 19, 2009
• "The sum which says 27+2 is wrong it is suppossed to be 27-2 which equals 25 so inturn the sum is wrong."
• Mr Barker's Year 7 (Best Set?), William Farr Welton
• Friday, June 19, 2009
• "The £30 was the Red Herring. The bill was actually £25 plus a £2 tip totalling £27 so they paid the correct amount. Usually the tip should be 10% so if I was the witer I would be looking for an extra 50p!"
• Becky Taylor, Crookfur Primary
• Friday, June 19, 2009
• "If they were ment to pay £25 and then they got £3 back that would be £28
  then add the £2 the waitor got is £30."
• Gwindley, St Peter In Thanet Ce Junior School
• Friday, June 19, 2009
• "£8.33 per person for meal ( £25/3)
  £0.67 per person went to waiter = £2.00 (3 x £0.67)
  
  £1.00 per person returned =£3.00
  total £25 +£3 + £2= £30
  Meal costs £8.33 per person not £9 as stated in question."
• Mr C, Bexhill HIgh
• Friday, June 19, 2009
• "Initially they paid £30, the waiter kept £2 so in fact they paid £28 - £3 returned = £25. There is no missing £1."
• Jonathan, St Aidans C O E Tech College
• Monday, June 22, 2009
• "The restaurant gets £25
  the people altogether get £3
  and the waiter gets £2
  add them together and you get £30."
• Adam, Leeds UK
• Monday, September 14, 2009
• "Easy you minus the £2 from 27
  why on earth would you add it to make £29
  30 - 3 + 2 will always leave you a pound short
  100 - 3 + 2 = 99 (1 pound short)
  50 - 3 + 2 = 49 (1 pound short)
  5 - 3 + 2 = 4 (1 pound short)
  the answer is 30 - 3 - 2 = 25."
• Cherie Glennon, Brooksbank School
• Tuesday, September 15, 2009
• "If you approach the problem from the other direction or backwards i.e.
  The 3 men have paid £25 in total for the meal. They then recieve £1 each
  making £28 and the 'dumb waiter' gets £2 = £30."

How did you use this starter? Can you suggest how teachers could present or develop this resource? Do you have any comments? It is always useful to receive feedback and helps make this free resource even more useful for Maths teachers anywhere in the world. Click here to enter your comments.